Statistika nemackih firmi za kvalitet i sigurnost: Dekre i TUV-a o kvarovima i pouzdanosti automobila. Zanimljivo je da je Dekra radila izvestaj na osnovu kilometraze, sa vozilima podeljenim u kategorije (obuhvaceno oko 15 miliona automobila), dok je TUV podelio automobile na osnovu starosti vozila bez obzira na kategoriju... i obuhvata, kako navode procenat "ozbiljnih" kvarova zabelezenim kod servisera (uradjeno na osnovu 7miliona vozila). Nazalost ovi izvestaji obuhvataju samo vozila vozena u Nemackoj, ali ipak moze da se koristi kao neko merilo.


DEKRA

Izvestaj za 2008.
MALI AUTOMOBILI
- Mitsubishi Colt (do 30,000km)
- Mazda2 (30,000-60,000km)
- Honda Jazz (60,000-90,000km)

KOMPAKTNI AUTOMOBILI
- BMW 1 -Series(do 30,000km)
- Skoda Octavia (30,000-60,000km)
- Volkswagen Golf V (60,000-90,000km)

AUTOMOBILI SREDNJE VELICINE
- Peugeot 407 (do 50,000km)
- Toyota Avensis (50,000-100,000km)
- Audi A4 (100,000-150,000km)

AUTOMOBILI VISE KLASE
- Audi A6 (do 50,000km)
- Audi A8 (50,000-100,000km)
- BMW 5-Series (100,000-150,000km)

SPORTSKI AUTOMOBILI
- Mercedes SLK (do 50,000km)
- Audi A4 Cabrio (50,000-100,000km)
- Mazda MX-5 (100,000-150,000km)

SUV
- Hyundai Tuscon (do 50,000km)
- BMW X3 (50,000-100,000km)
- BMW X5 (100,000-150,000km)

MPV
- SEAT Altea (do 50,000km)
- Volkswagen Touran (50,000-100,000km)
- Volkswagen Touran (100,000-150,000km)

Kao najpouzdaniji automobil je ocenjen BMW serije 1, koji je prosao 97,8% Dekrinih testova. Studija je obuhvatila 150 razlicitih modela automobila.


Izvestaj za 2009.
MALI AUTOMOBILI
- Renault Clio III, Toyota Aygo i Mazda2 (do 50,000km)
- Mazda2, Honda Jazz i Mitsubishi Colt (50,000-100,000km)
- Audi A2, Toyota Yaris i Ford Fiesta/Fusion (100,000-150,000km)

KOMPAKTNI AUTOMOBILI
- Toyota Prius, Ford Focus i Mazda3 (do 50,000km)
- VW Golf V/Jetta/Golf Plus, Mazda3 i Skoda Octavia (50,000-100,000km)
- Skoda Octavia, Ford Focus i VW Golf V/Jetta/Golf Plus (100,000-150,000km)

AUTOMOBILI SREDNJE VELICINE
- Saab 9-3, Audi A4 i Toyota Avensis (do 50,000km)
- Saab 9-3, Audi A4 i Toyota Avensis (50,000-100,000km)
- Audi A4, Toyota Avensis i Mazda6 (100,000-150,000km)

AUTOMOBILI VISE KLASE
- Audi A6, BMW 7 i BMW 5 (do 50,000km)
- Audi A8, BMW 7 i Audi A6 (50,000-100,000km)
- Audi A6, BMW 7 i BMW 5 (100,000-150,000km)

SPORTSKI AUTOMOBILI
- Mercedes SLK, BMW Z4 Cabrio/Coupe i BMW 3 Cabrio (do 50,000km)
- Mercedes SLK, Audi A4 Cabrio i BMW Z4 Cabrio/Coupe (50,000-100,000km)
- BMW 3 Cabrio, Mazda MX-5 i Audi TT Cabrio/Coupe (100,000-150,000km)

SUV
- BMW X3, Subaru Forester i Hyundai Tucson (do 50,000km)
- Porsche Cayenne, BMW X3 i Subaru Forester (50,000-100,000km)
- Toyota RAV4, BMW X5 i Mitsubishi Pajero (100,000-150,000km)

MPV
- Ford S-Max/Galaxy, Mazda5 i Seat Altea/XL/Toledo (do 50,000km)
- Seat Altea/XL/Toledo, Ford C-Max i VW Touran (50,000-100,000km)
- VW Touran, VW Caddy i VW T5 (100,000-150,000km)

Kao najpouzdaniji se pokazao Ford S-Max/Galaxy, koji je prosao 96,7% testova, a odmah iza njega i Renault Clio III, kao i Mazda 5.


Izvestaj za 2010.
MALI AUTOMOBILI
- Opel Corsa, by Smart Fortwo i Toyota Yaris (do 50,000km)
- Toyota Yaris, by Renault Clio i Mazda2 (50,000-100,000km)
- Honda Jazz, by Audi A2 i Ford Fiesta (100,000-150,000km)

KOMPAKTNI AUTOMOBILI
- Toyota Prius, by SEAT Leon i Mazda3 (do 50,000km)
- Mercedes-Benz B-Class, VW Golf/Jetta/Golf Plus i Skoda Octavia (50,000-100,000km)
- Skoda Octavia, VW Golf/Jetta/Golf Plus i Ford Focus (100,000-150,000km)

AUTOMOBILI SREDNJE VELICINE
- Audi A4, Mercedes-Benz C-Class i BMW 3-Series (do 50,000km)
- BMW 3-Series, Volvo S40/V50 i VW Passat (50,000-100,000km)
- Volvo S40/V50, BMW 3-Series i VW Passat (100,000-150,000km)

AUTOMOBILI VISE KLASE
- Audi A6, Mercedes-Benz S-Class i BMW 5-Series (do 50,000km)
- Audi A6, Audi A8 i Mercedes-Benz S-Class (50,000-100,000km)
- Audi A8, Audi A6 i BMW 5-Series (100,000-150,000km)

SPORTSKI AUTOMOBILI
- Mazda MX-5, VW Eos i BMW 6-Series Coupe/Cabrio (do 50,000km)
- Mercedes SLK, Opel Tigra Twin Top i BMW Z4 Cabrio/Coupe (50,000-100,000km)
- Porsche 911, Mercedes-Benz CLK i Mazda MX-5 (100,000-150,000km)

SUV
- BMW X3, Toyota RAV4 i Porsche Cayenne (do 50,000km)
- Porsche Cayenne, BMW X3 i Toyota RAV4 (50,000-100,000km)
- BMW X3, VW Touareg i BMW X5 (100,000-150,000km)

MPV
- Nissan Note, Skoda Roomster i Ford Galaxy/S-Max (do 50,000km)
- Mazda5, SEAT Altea/Toledo i Ford Galaxy/S-Max (50,000-100,000km)
- Opel Zafira, VW Touran i Ford C-Max (100,000-150,000km)

Kao najpouzdanije vozilo u kategoriji do 50 000km se pokazala Opel Corsa D koja je prosla 97,6% testova, a iza nje su se nasli Audi A4 i Mercedes C klase. Ali kao najbolji su sve tri kategorije po kilometrazi je bio Audi A6, a kao drugi i treci BMW X3 i BMW serija 3.



TUV

Izvestaj za 2008.
2-3 GODINE STAROSTI(prosecno 4.8% kvarova)
1. Mazda3 (1.2%)
2. Mazda2 (1.4%)
3. VW Golf/Ford Fusion (2.2%)
5. Honda Jazz (2.3%)
***
112. Nissan Primera (9.2%)
113. Renault Laguna (12.6%)
114. Renault Espace (12.7%)
115. Chrysler PT Cruiser (13.5%)
116. Kia Carnival (20.1%)

4-5 GODINA STAROSTI(prosecno 8.9% kvarova)
1. Porsche 911 (2.8%)
2. Honda Jazz (2.9%)
3. Subaru Legacy (3.4%)
4. Porsche Boxster (3.6%)
5. BMW 7 (3.9%)
***
107. Kia Rio (15.3%)
108. Peugeot 106 (16.7%)
109. Chrysler Voyager (18.8%)
110. Renault Laguna (22.3%)
111. Kia Carnival (27.6%)

6-7 GODINA STAROSTI(prosecno 13.3% kvarova)
1. Toyota RAV4 (3.6%)
2. Porsche 911 (4.5%)
3. Porsche Boxster (4.6%)
4. Mercedes SL (4.8%)
5. Mazda Demio (5.7%)
***
95. Seat Alhambra (20.3%)
96. Ford Ka (20.4%)
97. Alfa Romeo 145/146 (25.9%)
98. Chrysler Voyager (27%)
99. Kia Carnival (32.9%)

8-9 GODINA STAROSTI(prosecno 18.1% kvarova)
1. Porsche Boxster (4.2%)
2. Porsche 911 (5.8%)
3. Mercedes SL (7.3%)
4. Subaru Forester (7.4%)
5. Toyota RAV4 (7.9%)
***
84. Citroen Berlingo (26.3%)
85. Ford Ka (26.8%)
86. Chrysler Voyager (26.9%)
87. Suzuki Wagon R+ (28.1%)
88. Renault Twingo (30.2%)

10-11 GODINA STAROSTI(prosecno 22.5% kvarova)
1. Porsche 911 (5%)
2. Mercedes SL (6.3%)
3. Toyota RAV4 (8.4%)
4. Mercedes SLK (9.7%)
5. Toyota Starlet/Subaru Legacy (10.6%)
***
68. Seat Toledo (30.5%)
69. Chrysler Voyager/Renault Megane (31.2%)
71. Renault Twingo (32.8%)
72. Alfa Romeo 145/146 (32.9%)

Izvestaj za 2009.
2-3 GODINE STAROSTI(prosek 5.0% kvarova)
1. Toyota Corolla Verso (2%)
2. Mazda2 (2.1%)
3. Porsche 911 tied with Ford Fusion (2.2%)
5. Mazda3 tied with Ford Fiesta (2.7%)
***
112. Renault Espace tied with Fiat Stilo (10.1%)
114. Peugeot 407 (11.2%)
115. Chrysler PT Cruiser tied with Seat Arosa (11.5%)
117. Kia Carnival (26.1%)

4-5 GODINA STAROSTI(prosek 9.3% kvarova)
1. Porsche Boxster (3.6%)
2. Porsche 911 (3.6%)
3. Subaru Forester (3.7%)
4. Honda Jazz (3.9%)
5. Audi A8 (4.3%)
***
105. Renault Kangoo (17%)
106. Peugeot 106 (17.1%)
107. Chrysler PT Cruiser (18%)
108. Renault Laguna (19.3%)
109. Kia Carnival (29.3%)

6-7 GODINA STAROSTI(prosek 14.0% kvarova)
1. Porsche 911 (4.5%)
2. Porsche Boxster (4.7%)
3. Subaru Forester (6.4%)
4. Toyota RAV4 (6.7%)
5. Mercedes SLK (6.8%)
***
90. Fiat Stilo/Bravo/Brava (21.1%)
91. Renault Kangoo (22.2%)
92. Chrysler PT Cruiser (23.9%)
93. Renault Laguna (24.5%)
94. Kia Carnival (36.1%)

8-9 GODINA STAROSTI(prosek 18.3% kvarova)
1. Porsche Boxster (5.2%)
2. Porsche 911 (5.3%)
3. Toyota RAV4 (6.7%)
4. Mercedes SLK (8.3%)
5. Mazda Demio (8.4%)
***
83. Fiat Punto (24.9%)
84. Renault Twingo (25.5%)
85. Skoda Felicia (27.5%)
86. Ford Ka (28.7%)
87. Alfa Romeo 145/146 (30%)

10-11 GODINA STAROSTI(prosek 23.3% kvarova)
1. Porsche 911 (5.6%)
2. Toyota RAV4 (9%)
3. Toyota Starlet (10%)
4. Mercedes SLK (11.7%)
5. BMW Z3 (15.2%)
***
64. Seat Leon/Toledo tied with Skoda Felicia (30.3%)
66. Alfa Romeo 145/146 (31.8%)
67. Renault Twingo (32.6%)
68. Ford Ka (33.1%)

Izvestaj za 2010.
2-3 GODINE STAROSTI
1. Porsche 911 (1.9%)
2. Mazda2 (2.4%)
3. VW Golf Puls tied with Ford Fusion and Mazda3 (2.6%)
***
125. Kia Carnival (29.3%)
124. Chrysler PT Cruiser (13.8%)
123. Peugeot 407 (12.1%)
122. Hyundai Atos/Prime (10.3%)
121. Chrysler Voyager (10.1%)

4-5 GODINA STAROSTI
1. VW Golf Plus (3.4%)
2. Toyota Corolla Verso (3.6%)
3. BMW 1-Series (3.7%)
4. Mazda3 (4.1%)
5. Porsche Boxster tied with Renault Modus (4.6%)
***
118. Kia Carnival (28.2%)
116. Renault Laguna tied with Peugeot 106 (21.9%)
115. Chrysler PT Cruiser (20.9%)
114. Renault Espace (20.0%)

6-7 GODINA STAROSTI
1. Porsche 911 (6.1%)
2. Toyota RAV4 (6.3%)
3. Porsche Boxster (6.6%)
4. Honda Jazz (7.2%)
5. Opel Meriva (7.3%)
***
99. Kia Carnival (37.5%)
98. Renault Laguna (26.0%)
97. SEAT Alhambra (25.3%)
96. Fiat Stilo (24.8%)
95. Chrysler PT Cruiser (24.4%)

8-9 GODINA STAROSTI
1. Toyota RAV4 (6.6%)
2. Porsche Boxster (7.0%)
3. Porsche 911 (7.6%)
4. Subaru Forester (9.6%)
5. Mazda MX-5 (10.4%)
***
82. Chrysler Voyager (32.5%)
81. Ford Ka (28.7%)
80. SEAT Alhambra (28.5%)
78. Fiat Bravo/Brava tied with Ford Galaxy (26.6%)

10-11 GODINA STAROSTI
1. Toyota RAV4 (10.2%)
2. Toyota Starlet tied with Subaru Forester (12.0%)
4. Toyota Corolla (12.%)
5. Mercedes-Benz SLK (13.0%)
***
71. Ford Ka (35.0%)
69. Renault Twingo tied with Chrysler Voyager (33.0%)
68. Alfa Romeo 156 (32.0%)
67. Fiat Seicento (31.7%)